Professional legal aid often ensures successful appeals against the decision of the first instance court. See for yourself how events can develop with one fresh example.
The pensioner, a disabled person of the III group, was threatened with a fine in the amount of UAH 10 200.00 and deprivation of a driver’s license for a period of 1 year.
According to the ruling of the local court, on August 2, 2020 at 1:45 am, a citizen was driving a Mercedes Benz car while intoxicated, thereby violating clause 2.9 (a) of the traffic rules. The events took place in the regional center of the Khmelnytsky region.
The conclusion of the court on the guilt of a citizen of committing an offense, under Part 1 of Article 130 of the Code of Administrative Offenses, was based on:
How did the lawyer act in this case?
Protection of interests in the court of appeal was built brilliantly!
The following arguments were used to appeal against the ruling of the local court:
Firstly, the citizen brought to justice did not drive the car that appears in the case at all. From the video, it is impossible to reliably confirm the fact that it was he who was driving.
Secondly, the examination for the state of alcoholic intoxication at the place where the car stopped was carried out by police officers with violations. Namely, there are no testimonies of two witnesses confirming the refusal of a citizen to undergo an appropriate examination.
Thirdly, the examination for the state of intoxication in a medical institution was carried out in violation of the requirements of part 4 of article 266 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of Administrative Offenses, more than 2:00 hours after the establishment of the grounds for its implementation.
Even in the absence of legal knowledge, the ukrainian driver is likely to react to the mention of the wording “subjection to liability under part 1 of article 130 of the Code of Administrative Offenses”. A significant number of judgments are issued by the courts under this article. Along with this, the decision of the local court is not always the point in such a case.
What conclusions did the court of appeal make?
The report does not indicate the witnesses who saw driver’s refusing to carry out an examination for the state of intoxication at the place where the vehicle stopped. Also, the materials of the case do not contain their written explanations. Such witnesses were not questioned by the court of first instance.
According to the explanations of the police, there were allegedly such witnesses. However, their details were not indicated in the protocol, and they could not be identified from the video recording. The absence of witnesses gives the court of appeal grounds to believe that the record of an administrative offense is not proper, admissible evidence and an act of accusation.
Taking into account the above, the decision of the first instance court is subject to cancellation, and the proceedings on the case must be terminated due to the absence of an administrative offense in the actions of the citizen.
What can be summed up?
The police make mistakes in the preparation of materials on such cases. Using the services of a lawyer with experience, you can find the necessary leads to appeal against a decision in an administrative case.
The pensioner in this case got off with a “slight fright” thanks to the successful choice of a lawyer. And the police got another lesson – you need to be more careful and draw up documents carefully.
The grandmother in court proved her right to donate housing, despite the fact that her little granddaughter was registered in it! The Supreme court, by its conclusion in case No. 385/1598/18, determined that she is not a parent and not the one who replaces him, therefore, she is free in the right of alienation! Here […]
Judges, lawyers and justice officials love money too! Sometimes they use their connections and powers to improve their financial well-being! Some find themselves a lucrative “hobby”, for example, they are engaged in raiding. SBU officers uncovered a criminal scheme carried out by “raiders in court robes” with the help of lawyers and former employees of […]
Every self-respecting judge considers it his duty to reduce the lawyer’s fee as much as possible. This “phenomenon” is especially painful for lawyers working on an hourly basis. Why is that? God only knows! God knows, but for human rights defenders – absolutely incomprehensible, because the law and practice of the Armed Forces of Ukraine […]
In case of a shortage of funds for the purchase of housing, some citizens deliberately go to the purchase of an apartment or house “with debts.” If there is a significant debt for utilities, the owner is ready to sell his residential property at a good discount. The amount of such a discount usually covers […]
The first thing every citizen leaving his old place of work thinks about is how much money will fall on the card as a severance pay. Naturally, he wants more and that’s okay! The employer who signs the dismissal order is thinking about how to pay less! And he can be understood too! But, the […]
Family showdown is an eternal topic! Even the array of family legislation and court practice accumulated over decades does not contain answers to all questions regarding family relations! The Supreme Court once again had to figure out whether or not the testimonies of witnesses certified by a notary are considered legal confirmation of a civil […]
Entrust the settlement of legal disputes to the SPEAKER team of professionals! Get the highest level of legal services.
Мы готовы приступить к обсуждению Вашей задачи. Вскоре с Вами свяжемся.Back